Contribution Timing
When You Invest Matters More Than You Think
Lump sum vs. dollar cost averaging. Beginning of year vs. end of year. Learn how contribution timing affects your wealth and what research says works best.
The Decision
Lump Sum vs. Dollar Cost Averaging
You've decided to invest $12,000 this year. Should you:
Option A
Invest it all today?
Option B
Spread it across 12 monthly contributions?
Option C
Wait for a market dip?
The answer might surprise you. And understanding why could add tens of thousands to your wealth over time.
The Research
What Vanguard's Study Found
Lump Sum Wins 68% of the Time
Vanguard's landmark study analyzed historical rolling periods across US, UK, and Australian markets:
- Lump sum beat DCA in 68% of historical 12-month periods
- Average outperformance: 2.3% over 12-month DCA periods
- Results held consistently across all three major markets
Translation: If you have money to invest, invest it now.
Why Lump Sum Usually Wins: The Math
$120,000 at 7% annual return (one year):
| Strategy | Year-End Value |
|---|---|
| Lump sum January 1st | $128,400 |
| Monthly DCA ($10K/month) | ~$125,600 |
The lump sum gains: Full year of returns on full amount.
DCA loses: Earlier contributions grow, but later ones miss growth.
The Exception
When Dollar Cost Averaging Wins
DCA shines in one specific scenario: when markets drop significantly after you would have invested.
2008-2009 Financial Crisis Example
Scenario: $100,000 to invest starting October 2008
Lump Sum (Oct 2008)
Invested $100K at S&P 969
= 103 shares
DCA ($10K/month)
Bought throughout the crash
= 126 shares accumulated
DCA accumulated 23% more shares by buying throughout the crash.
The Regret Factor
DCA wins psychologically when markets drop after investment.
| Strategy | Feeling | Reality |
|---|---|---|
| Lump sum | "I lost $30,000!" | Paper loss; will recover |
| DCA | "I bought the dip!" | Slightly better outcome |
DCA doesn't protect wealth — it protects emotions.
The Hybrid
Best of Both Worlds Strategies
Value Averaging
Invest more when prices are low, less when high. Target a fixed portfolio value increase each month. Research shows this slightly outperforms pure DCA in volatile markets.
Invest Today, DCA the Rest
Got a $50K bonus? Invest 60% immediately, DCA the remaining 40% over 6 months. Captures most lump sum advantage while reducing regret risk.
Within-Year Timing
Beginning vs. End of Year Matters Too
IRA Contribution Timing Impact
Contributing January 1st vs. April 15th (following year):
| Timing | Days Invested | 30-Year Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Jan 1 Year 1 | 10,950 days | $98,358 more |
| Apr 15 Year 2 | 10,485 days | — |
Contributing early each year adds ~$100K over a career.
Paycheck Frequency Matters
Biweekly (26/year) vs. Monthly (12/year) contributions:
| Frequency | Annual Contribution | 30-Year Value at 7% |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly $500 | $6,000 | $566,765 |
| Biweekly $231 | $6,006 | $569,892 |
Biweekly contributions grow ~$3,127 more due to slightly earlier average investment.
The Dangerous Strategy
Market Timing: I'll Wait for a Dip
⚠️ The Most Dangerous Timing Strategy
Problem 1: You Never Know It's a Dip
You only know it was a dip after recovery. Today's "high" often becomes tomorrow's "low".
Problem 2: Missing the Best Days
Missing the 10 best market days over 20 years (1999-2018):
| Scenario | Ending Value ($10K) |
|---|---|
| Stayed invested | $29,845 |
| Missed 10 best days | $14,895 |
| Missed 20 best days | $9,359 |
| Missed 30 best days | $6,213 |
The best days often come right after the worst days — exactly when people are on the sidelines.
Special Situations
Optimal Timing for Different Scenarios
Windfall (Bonus, Inheritance)
1) Immediately fund tax-advantaged accounts (401K, IRA, IUL), 2) Keep 6-12 month emergency fund, 3) High risk tolerance: 100% lump sum. Moderate: 60/40. Low: 50/50 DCA over 12 months.
401(k) Contributions
Max early in year if possible, BUT check if your employer match requires spreading throughout the year. Some plans match per-paycheck, so front-loading means missing match.
IRA Contributions
January 1st of tax year (not April 15th of following year). Gives you 15 extra months of growth. This alone is worth ~$100K over a 30-year career.
IUL Premium Timing
Level monthly premiums work best for IUL. Matches income patterns, maintains policy in good standing, and annual crediting means daily timing doesn't matter much.
Psychology
The Strategy You'll Actually Follow
Theoretical vs. Practical Optimal
| Strategy | Theoretical Optimal | Practical Optimal |
|---|---|---|
| Lump sum | Best expected return | Best if you won't panic |
| DCA | Slightly lower return | Best if it keeps you invested |
| Waiting for dip | Never optimal | Common (but costly) behavior |
DCA that you execute beats lump sum that you hesitate on.
Frequently Asked Questions
Build Your Investment Timing System
The best time to invest was yesterday. The second best time is today. We'll help you create an automated contribution schedule that captures the time value of money without the stress of market timing.